Zimbabwe’s Special Economic Zones Are A Wildcard
By Mumera Wisdom , 15 , Aug 2016 in News Slider
0 0Harare, Zimbabwe (News of the South)-Government’s drive for Special Economic Zones (SEZs) as it seeks to awaken the comatose economy has elicited a cautionary analogue of the African context in which the initiative has fared in less glowing terms.
Special Economic Zones (SEZs) are designated geographical regions which operate under specific economic regulations that are different from other areas in the same country.
Usually the goal of a zone is to increase Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) by foreign investors, typically an international business or a multinational corporation (MNC).
In line with the economic blueprint, ZimAsset, government has earmarked seven SEZs such as the diamond cutting and polishing in Mutare, industrial manufacturing in Bulawayo, petroleum and IT in Harare, chemical and gas production in Lupane, tourism in Gwayi-Victoria Falls, agro processing in Norton and textile processing in Kadoma.
Currently the SEZ Bill, initially tabled in 2015, is undergoing due processes and consultations which will see it being passed into an Act as a legal and regulatory framework to govern the operationalization of the initiative.
Consultations are still ongoing on the use of Sunway City Integrated Industrial Park in Harare, the Victoria Falls financial hub and the Bulawayo industrial hub which have been selected for trial runs before the SEZ initiative is spread to the rest of the country.
This has however drawn a warning analogue from the Zimbabwe Economic Policy Analysis and Research Unit (ZEPARU) which contends that SEZs are largely a tenuous initiative that is unreliable.
According to the institution SEZs have been a tale of mixed fortunes almost everywhere else save for great economic achievements mainly in Asian countries such as China, Singapore, Malaysia and South Korea.
In China the Shenzhen SEZ has developed from a small village into a city with a population of over 10 million within 20 years but in Africa the only notable SEZ has been in Mauritius.
Elsewhere in Africa SEZs have been created in Lesotho, Madagascar and Kenya where the results have been a mixture of the commendable and the pathetic.
“The vast majority of SEZs have not had a transformative impact”.
“In some instances SEZs in Africa are not integrated effectively with the local economy, and did not facilitate industrial upgrading, or act as a catalyst of wider economic reforms”.
“Other reasons for this poor performance could include a poor choice of location and insufficient strategic planning and management; inadequate infrastructure (for example, in access roads, energy, water and ineffective policy, regulatory and institutional frameworks”, the research institution says.
A key lesson drawn from international experience according to ZEPARU is that SEZs are not a panacea to solving all economic challenges.
Instead, they catalyse deeper economic reforms and become a major engine for national development through backward and forward linkages with the rest of the domestic economy.
“In this regard they need to be complemented by the implementation of other policy initiatives and strategies outlined in the country’s development programme ZimAsset”.
The needed fundamentals for successful SEZs in Zimbabwe according to ZEPARU, is picture of the nearly impossible for a country currently struggling to pay its civil servants.
“Delivery of external infrastructure (power, roads, water, waste management and information and communication technology (ICT)) is critical”.
“Sound legal and regulatory framework and effective institutions are critical: the regulatory institution must be autonomous and adequately funded”.
“Both a strong and long-term commitment from government and active participation of the private sector is essential and linkages with the local market need to be strong: zones need to build on local comparative advantage in priority sectors”, it says.
The government has been traversing a medley of paths foraging for the way back to a revived economy a journey that is proving beyond their ability as the ruling party has also found itself at political crossroads.
In the Zimbabwean context initiatives to reduce the debt burden, expanding and modernising infrastructure; improvement in public service delivery; conducive doing business environment and improvements in productivity will all facilitate the success of the proposed SEZs.
Furthermore, deeper research and dialogue is still required to inform policy decisions and implementation strategies to ensure SEZs have a transformational impact in Zimbabwe.
The country has previously had Export Processing Zones (EPZ), a variation of the ESZs aimed at promoting exports, which however failed after being stymied by policy changes.
The SEZ bill has also come under attack from labour activists such as the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) who say it has archaic provisions which have been defended by Macro-Economic Planning and Investment Promotion Permanent Secretary Desire Sibanda as justified pains.
0
