Dual Legal Systems: When Customary Law And Constitutional Law Collide
By Princess Eugene Majuru
One of the most historically rooted yet legally complex features of Zimbabwe’s constitutional order is the coexistence of customary law and general law. The 2013 Constitution formally recognises customary law as part of the legal system, while simultaneously affirming the supremacy of the Constitution. This creates a dual legal structure where two systems operate side by side—but not always in equal alignment.
The result is a constitutional arrangement where customary law is recognised, yet ultimately subordinate, producing both integration and tension within the same legal framework.
- The Supremacy of the Constitution
The foundation of legal hierarchy is found in Section 2(1), which provides:
“This Constitution is the supreme law of Zimbabwe and any law, practice, custom or conduct inconsistent with it is invalid to the extent of the inconsistency.”
What this establishes:
the Constitution overrides all other laws
customary law is valid only if consistent with it
legal hierarchy is clearly defined
This ensures uniformity in legal authority.
- Recognition of Customary Law
Despite constitutional supremacy, customary law is explicitly recognised.
Section 89 provides:
“Customary law is part of the law of Zimbabwe, except to the extent that it is inconsistent with this Constitution or any Act of Parliament.”
Key implication:
customary law is legally valid
it operates alongside general law
it is not outside the formal legal system
This creates a dual legal framework.
- The Role of Traditional Institutions
Section 282(1) provides:
“Traditional leaders must uphold the Constitution and the customs and traditions of their communities…”
What this shows:
customary governance is institutionally recognised
traditional leaders operate within constitutional limits
cultural authority is formally integrated
However:
authority is conditional, not autonomous
- The Structural Tension: Two Legal Logics
The Constitution brings together two distinct legal traditions:
(1) Customary legal system:
based on tradition and community practice
flexible and context-specific
often unwritten and relational
(2) Constitutional/general legal system:
codified and hierarchical
uniform and state-enforced
interpretation through courts
Result:
two systems with different foundations operating under one legal hierarchy
- Areas of Legal Conflict
Tensions often arise in areas such as:
inheritance and succession
marriage and family law
land allocation and use
community dispute resolution
In such cases:
customary law may reflect community norms
constitutional law may prioritise rights-based principles
Core issue:
which system prevails in practice can depend on interpretation and context
- The Role of the Courts
Courts become the final arbiters of conflict between systems.
Section 165(1) provides:
“The judicial authority of Zimbabwe vests in the courts, which are independent and subject only to this Constitution and the law.”
Implication:
courts determine validity of customary practices
constitutional interpretation overrides conflicting customs
judicial interpretation shapes the balance between systems
- The Deeper Constitutional Question
The dual system raises a fundamental question:
Can two legal systems truly coexist equally when one is constitutionally supreme over the other?
The Constitution attempts to answer this by:
recognising customary law
but limiting it through constitutional supremacy
This creates a hierarchy rather than parity.
Recognition Without Equality of Legal Authority
Zimbabwe’s Constitution formally integrates customary law into the national legal system through Section 89, while maintaining constitutional supremacy under Section 2. It acknowledges tradition, culture, and indigenous legal practices as part of the national identity.
However, the relationship between the two systems is not equal—it is hierarchical.
The result is a legal order where:
customary law is recognised
constitutional law is dominant
and courts determine the boundary between them
In this sense, Zimbabwe’s Constitution does not erase customary law, but it does place it within a controlled legal framework.
The ongoing constitutional challenge is not recognition itself, but balance:
how to respect indigenous legal systems while maintaining a unified constitutional order that guarantees consistent rights and legal certainty.
0Comments
About Author
HRH Princess Eugene Majuru
Princess Eugene Majuru is a distinguished author, historian, and media entrepreneur, and a direct descendant of the royal Mbari clan of Harare. As the sovereign custodian of Harare’s heritage, she has dedicated her life to preserving and promoting Zimbabwean culture, history, and traditions. Princess Eugene is the author of acclaimed works including Chosen, A Concise History of Harare, and Reclaiming Heritage. As the founder of News of The South, she leads one of Zimbabwe’s premier media platforms, hosting press conferences and providing insightful commentary on social, cultural, and heritage issues. Passionate about education, heritage, and civic engagement, Princess Eugene blends her royal lineage with modern thought leadership to inspire and inform audiences locally and internationally.

