Constitutional Culture and Institutional Behaviour: Why Law Alone Does Not Guarantee Governance
By Princess Eugene Majuru
A constitution is often understood as a legal document that structures power and defines rights. However, in practice, constitutional systems are shaped not only by written rules but also by institutional culture—the habits, norms, interpretations, and behaviours of those who operate within state structures. Zimbabwe’s 2013 Constitution establishes a detailed framework of rights, institutions, and procedures, yet its effectiveness ultimately depends on whether constitutional culture aligns with constitutional text.
This introduces a deeper question: can a constitution function as intended if the political and institutional culture does not fully support it?
1. The Principle of Constitutional Supremacy
Section 2(1) provides:
“This Constitution is the supreme law of Zimbabwe and any law, practice, custom or conduct inconsistent with it is invalid to the extent of the inconsistency.”
What this establishes:
- constitutional supremacy over all other forms of authority
- invalidation of inconsistent practices
- legal hierarchy of norms
On paper, this is absolute.
2. The Gap Between Law and Practice
Despite constitutional supremacy, governance often depends on:
- administrative habits
- institutional traditions
- political norms
- enforcement consistency
This creates a gap:
what the Constitution requires and what institutions routinely do may not always align
3. Institutional Behaviour as a Constitutional Factor
Institutions do not operate in a vacuum. Their behaviour is shaped by:
- leadership culture
- historical practice
- resource constraints
- political environment
- training and professional norms
Result:
constitutional compliance is not automatic—it is behavioural
4. The Role of Public Administration
Public administration is the daily interface of the Constitution. Even where Section 68 guarantees administrative justice:
“Every person has a right to administrative conduct that is lawful, prompt, efficient, reasonable, proportionate, impartial and both substantively and procedurally fair.”
Implementation depends on:
- institutional efficiency
- accountability systems
- administrative discipline
- professional ethics
5. Courts and Constitutional Culture
Even judicial interpretation (Section 46 and Section 176) is influenced by:
- legal tradition
- training of judges
- precedent
- interpretive philosophy
This means:
constitutional meaning evolves through institutional practice, not text alone
6. The Risk of Formal Compliance Without Substantive Change
A state may:
- follow constitutional procedures
- maintain formal legal compliance
- establish institutions on paper
but still face challenges if:
- institutional culture resists change
- accountability is weak in practice
- enforcement is inconsistent
Result:
constitutional form without full constitutional substance
7. The Core Constitutional Tension
Zimbabwe’s Constitution creates two layers:
(1) Legal architecture:
- clear rights
- strong institutional design
- constitutional supremacy
(2) Cultural reality:
- institutional behaviour
- administrative practice
- political and bureaucratic norms
A Constitution That Requires Culture to Function
Zimbabwe’s Constitution is structurally strong, comprehensive, and rights-based. However, its effectiveness is not determined solely by its provisions, but by how those provisions are interpreted, implemented, and internalised within state institutions.
In this sense:
- law defines the framework
- but culture determines performance
- and institutions mediate the gap between the two
The result is a constitutional system where success depends not only on legal design, but on the development of a consistent constitutional culture across all levels of governance.
The enduring constitutional question is therefore:
0can a constitution transform a state, or must the state’s institutional culture transform for the constitution to truly function?
Comments
About Author
HRH Princess Eugene Majuru
Princess Eugene Majuru is a distinguished author, historian, and media entrepreneur, and a direct descendant of the royal Mbari clan of Harare. As the sovereign custodian of Harare’s heritage, she has dedicated her life to preserving and promoting Zimbabwean culture, history, and traditions. Princess Eugene is the author of acclaimed works including Chosen, A Concise History of Harare, and Reclaiming Heritage. As the founder of News of The South, she leads one of Zimbabwe’s premier media platforms, hosting press conferences and providing insightful commentary on social, cultural, and heritage issues. Passionate about education, heritage, and civic engagement, Princess Eugene blends her royal lineage with modern thought leadership to inspire and inform audiences locally and internationally.

