Please follow and like us:
Pin Share

By Ndaba Nhuku.

London, England (News of The South) – The word ‘Sanction’ has almost two opposite meanings: to sanction can be to approve of something, but it can also mean to punish, or speak harshly to.
Masters (2024) in the Council on Foreign Relations defined economic sanctions as ‘the withdrawal of customary trade and financial relations for foreign- and security-policy purposes. Sanctions may be comprehensive, prohibiting commercial activity with regard to an entire country, like the long-standing U.S. embargo of Cuba, or they may be targeted, blocking transactions by and with particular businesses, groups, or individuals.’



However, since 9/11, countries like Zimbabwe had a new type of sanctions imposed on the country’s leadership. The sanctions were called targeted or so-called smart sanctions, and their purpose is to mitigate the impact of economic sanctions on innocent civilians. Generally, sanctions are imposed in numerous routes; freezing bank accounts, travel bans, freezing assets, arms embargoes, capital restraints, decrease in foreign aid, and trade and service provision restrictions.

WHY USE SANCTION AS PUNISHMENT?
“You can impose sanctions against another state because you want to see a change in behaviour of the other state,” says Professor Moritz Pieper, a lecturer in international relations at the University of Salford.
The idea and agenda for punishing or imposing sanctions at another state is that “the population gets angry, and will demand from its own government to do something to rectify the situation.” Simply put, it is a desire for the population to protest and change a government or to force it to change its conduct or policies. Powerful governments and multinational bodies usually impose economic sanctions as a way of attempting to change the strategic decisions of another country or individuals who are threatening their interests or who are assumed to be violating international norms of behaviour.

Usually countries also impose sanctions in retaliation to other countries’ sanctions, for example, in 2014 and in February 2022 Russia did so in response to sanctions imposed on her by the West. Generally, and ideally, sanctions should be resorted to after diplomatic efforts have failed. Sanctions are usually not successful, but remain an effective foreign policy tool to deter targeted states from going against the interests of the powerful state/s or organisations imposing the sanctions.
Generally, sanctions tend to be economically ruinous both ways, but mainly on the country they are imposed on. For example, an import sanction will adversely affect the targeted country’s exports by ensuring they are not purchased abroad. Thus, depending on the target country’s economic reliance on the exported good or service, as is the case with most developing countries, this could have a crippling effect. Mainly it is developing countries that endure sanctions from western regimes led by the US and the EU. The sanctions are aimed at instigating some political and economic instability that leads to change in a more dictatorship, or cause enough socioeconomic troubles to leave the country with power vacuum; thus, inciting regime change.



The target country’s socioeconomic suffering is ultimately borne by its citizens, who are then expected protest and effect a regime change. However, in most cases this achieves the opposite because in times of crisis sanctions tend to solidify the governing regime rather than overthrow it. In addition, a crippled country can easily become a breeding ground for extremism (Afghanistan, Somalia), a scenario most Western powers imposing sanctions are averse to dealing with.

The success of sanctions varies based on the number of parties involved, the more countries involved, the more effective they can be. Bilateral sanctions are more effective than unilateral sanctions, but the success rate, in general, is fairly low especially now that there are many countries not willing to harm their economies by partaking in sanctions. In most cases, sanctions cause economic damage without changing the target country’s policies, for example, Libya under Col. Gadhafi, Cuba under Fidel Castrol, among others. Sanctions are ultimately blunt tools of foreign policy whose implementation does not necessarily affect only the target economy, but even those imposing them as they hope that it will be a short term measure whose pressure and economic harm will compel the target country to change its policies or be forced out of power.
THE POWER OF AND OVER SANCTIONS

Choonara et al (2021) highlighted that worldwide, it is only the USA that has the capacity to impose meaningfully crippling economic sanctions on other countries simply because the US controls SWIFT. The SWIFT is the international payments system utilised for transferring money between countries and organisations within and outside those countries. The rest of the world, including the US itself, will mostly apply sanctions by using tariffs.

Russia and China and other countries are exploring novice means of setting up their own BRICS-based alternative to SWIFT. On the other hand, the EU is also exploring “special financial vehicles” to bypass SWIFT so that they can trade with countries sanctioned by the US such as Iran. However, the global banking system is so entangled such that it has not enabled the new alternatives to bear any fruit.
The US’s ownership of SWIFT is the main reason why the US dollar is the reserve currency of choice for majority countries of the world. Therefore, if an alternative to SWIFT is successful, the dollar will lose its reserve currency value leading to the market for US Treasury bonds drying up and leaving the US economy vulnerable, unable to service its huge debt. This would inevitably cause a global recession. Although no country would want to go through economic depression, the world is now tired of the US constantly imposing sanctions on other countries. This is primarily the reason why so many countries are eager to join BRICS, and more than 20 heads of state attended the BRICS summit in Kazan in October 2024 and had the US and its allies worried and giving condemning statements about Russia undermining the US dollar as an international system of financial settlements. Sanctions are essentially an economic war aimed at punishing or creating a regime change by prohibiting the use of the dollar and SWIFT cross border financial transaction systems. The US Treasury will utilise its SWIFT system to spy and track on how various nations, financial institutions and companies, and individuals around the world and the US move or spend money.



The US sanctions can be imposed on companies, individuals and trade sanctions against countries. The US government will urge its companies to avoid dealing with companies or in countries being sanctioned. Sanctioned individuals will not be allowed to enter the US and will be banned from any interaction with US government. Finally, the US government will also prohibit US companies and allied foreign governments and companies from trading with the affected countries. Thus, the allies and friends of the US are adversely impacted by its geopolitical decisions. This is why now most countries want to find alternative SWIFT as the US’ sanctions against other nations have made its friends lose interest in supporting it, and its allies no longer trust it. Therefore, overall US global influence is now in decline, making its foreign policy harder to achieve.
The US now faces huge challenges with the rise of India and Chinese manufacturing, industry, exports and economy which are ushering in alternatives to US trade and dollars. The strong Chinese and Russian economies are providing two alternatives to SWIFT and this hampers the US SWIFT effectiveness where sanctions are concerned because the US has no means of tracing cross border transaction if conducted in domestic currencies without using the SWIFT system.

To the indignant of other countries especially affected by the US sanctions, the SWIFT system and US dollar are solely an American source of revenue. This dwindles the US dollars as more nations and companies stop holding their reserves in US dollars. Thus, as more nations and companies find it cheaper to trade in domestic currencies, the US dollar reserves will continue to dwindle and other currencies take over. Choonara et al (2021) envisioned that a decline in the use of the SWIFT will increase the US debt forcing it either go into ‘isolation to build a self-sustainable economy or join the multipolar world as an equal and withdraw all sanctions.’ As of 2021, 60% of the world’s GDP was part of the multipolar world and the US dollar as the sole currency for purchasing oil was no longer dominant. Thus, once the US citizens are affected by the effects of the multipolar world, they will demand change and advocate for joint ventures with other nations, so that they protect themselves from the US weaponization of its dollar. The multipolar world has effectively destroyed a system whereby an international reserve currency is controlled by one nation or region at the expense of the whole world.

IMPACT OF SANCTIONS
Various adverse factors arise as a result of sanctions. For example sanctions will destroy economies and consequently exasperates other issues such as provision of quality of health, education, food security and safety, decreased spending on public health and increase in poverty among the poorest people. Since economic sanctions are usually applied by rich countries on poorer countries, this likely results in increased inequalities. It is mainly the US that has imposed economic sanctions on more countries than any other country with Cuba have endured comprehensive economic sanctions by the USA for more than 60 years. Comprehensive economic sanctions include bans on supplying or trading in food, medicines and medical equipment. Since imposed by the US, it was difficult for other countries to trade with Cuba. On the other hand, such sanctions aid to diminish US power and influence over other countries. For example, the US extraterritorial components on Cube were in 2019 declared illegal by the British Government stating ‘that under the UK Protection of Trading Interests Act 1980, it is illegal for UK companies to comply with extraterritorial legislation such as the US embargo’. The EU followed suit declaring the extraterritorial aspects of the US sanctions as illegal whilst the UN General Assembly had yearly overwhelmingly voted for the sanctions to be lifted.


Dendere (2022) highlighted that in Zimbabwe, economic sanctions imposed by the Western powers have been reported to have stifled development as the country is barred from accessing much-needed loans from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and other US led or influenced global entities. In addition, the sanctions have adversely impacted on Zimbabwe’s image worldwide; leaving it battered and affecting its tourist industry with no one wanting to engage in legitimate business in the country as most EU countries’ embassies closed. The closure of embassies meant the reduction and departure of the number of donors and the amount of aid the country accessed. This was all in the typical traditional aim of sanctions, that the citizens will rise against the Zanu regime and effect regime change. But as has been the case in countries where even comprehensive sanctions are imposed, citizens are generally the main victims of the sanctions and the elite is spared from the pain of their effects.

Fearful of repercussions of angering the US, most corporates reduced services or left the country altogether for neighbouring states. The country consequently faced a massive unemployment, shortage of forex, agriculture, health and education sectors nearly collapsed, and a massive brain drain followed to the benefit of the West and the neighbouring economic giant, South Africa. In addition, due to opposition political narratives, the western countries tend to reduce overseas aid to countries like Zimbabwe as a way of catering to these dissenting voices. Inevitably, this reduces the western influence and leaves room to other nations like China that are ready to work with the US’ errant governments like Zimbabwe without imposing any condition or applying any pressure regarding human rights or electoral reforms. As for the Zimbabwean situation, the western powers have entangled themselves in the notion that economic partnership is entangled to political stability.

DIMINISHING OF US INFLUENCE DUE TO UNPOPULAR SANCTIONS
As the US imposes its power over other nations to effect sanctions on others against their own will, they only do so fearful of being punished with aid withdrawal or heavy trade tariffs if they go against its will. In the process, the US has inevitably created dissention among several countries including some of its western allies. This is more visible when countries like the UK and EU declared illegal the US’ extraterritorial sanctions on Cuba. It is in the same vein that other countries like China and Russia, India and Brazil are taking over massive trade and resources exploitation in Africa as the western influence diminishes. This is because the West has angered African countries with so many political and economic demands and it is now forced to reduce its influence or leave the continent altogether. For example, the coup military leaders in the Alliance of Sahel states [Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger] have recently asked the US and French governments armies to leave, and to review their trade relationships with western corporates.

Meanwhile, the US and French military aid was replaced by the Russians. It is therefore clear that the western countries have unintentionally shut themselves from resources and influence in Africa, leaving these to Russia, and China which recently cancelled some African countries’ debts. It is the same situation the west finds itself in as it led by the US to impose sanction on Russia due to its war with Ukraine. Russia and China have hit back the US economic threats and sanctions by creating an alternative economic bloc, BRICS, which is massively expanding from the original 5 founding members.

Isolating Russia through comprehensive economic sanctions has not been effective so far. Instead the Russian economy has grown. And BRICS countries and many others continued trading with Russia with the western countries buying the same Russian oil at higher cost from BRICS members like India. Since Russia cannot officially sell its oil to EU, it sells it to India and India converts it into gas and sells to Europe. Meanwhile, many countries are fed up with American and western hypocrisy on issues around human rights and democracy which America tends to selectively, yet coerces, blackmails and bribes poorer nations to follow its foreign policy. This is why Russia has had active and passive supporters and sympathisers willing to defy America and continue trading with it.

In addition, to say the western sanctions against Russia are being implemented by the world is a misnomer; it would be more appropriate to call BRICS nations, the world!! The current population of the United States of America is 346,128,927, that of the UK is 69 296 408 and the EU 744 820 935. Combined, NATO members have a population of 973.04 million people. In comparison China’s 2024 population alone is estimated at 1,419,321,278 people whilst the current population of India, another BRIC founding member is 1,455,837,967. BRICS members control 50% of the world’s energy, while the G7 only controls 20%. Russia, Saudi Arabia and the UAE dominate. Furthermore, BRICS countries control 40% of the world’s industrial products, while the G7 only accounts for 25%. Again, a BRIC founding member China, dominates. Combined, the BRICS members encompass about 30% of the world’s land surface and 45% of world population. In 2023, over 3.3 billion people lived in the BRICS countries, including the world’s two most populous countries: India and China. With food production again, the BRICS countries control most of the world’s food production, about 50%. In comparison, the G7 only has 20%, with China, India, and Russia dominating.



The academic question then is; how does the G7 sanction the BRICS countries? If the G7 were to impose any economic comprehensive sanctions on BRICS nations, the effect would be disastrous for the G7 as the members would instantly face energy and food crises with skyrocketing prices, leading to social chaos and possible collapse. The BRICS desire to create an alternative banking system announced by the Russian President Putin, has drawn the ire of western leaders with the former UK Chancellor, Lord Lamont on the 3rd of December 2024 stating that, ‘’If it ever happened, it would be a major threat to the Western-led financial system, but above all it would make it impossible for the West to impose sanctions on countries like Russia, China or Iran or other malign countries.” Ironically, Lord Lamont seems to think countries having sanctions imposed on them must fold their hands and watch helplessly as the western counties punish them. Even the US President-Elect Trump widely believed to be President Putin’s admirer and friend also threatened huge tariffs to nations that will be involved in the BRICS creation of a counter banking system. All this points to how vulnerable the western banking system is now, and the decline of the US economic global superiority.

Pilkington (2022) observed that the US threatened but failed to sanction Chinese companies that persisted in trading with Russia. In defence, China undertook to protect its companies and citizens exposed to US unilateral economic sanctions against trading with Russia by taking ‘’all necessary measures to resolutely safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of Chinese enterprises and individuals.” China argued that the US unilateral sanctions had no foundation in international law and only caused “serious difficulties to the economy and people’s livelihood” in targeted nations. Again, the US faces a formidable economic giant going against its unilateral decisions in the global geopolitical theatre.

There is a general concern amongst several nations, worse so the BRICS, that although the Western powers have been promoting globalisation for more than three decades; they think they have some magical power to just withdraw from the global supply chains they led in creating ‘at the click of a finger.’ Understandably, to the world outside western societies, this is a political and economic delusion that is indeed likely to damage Western economic prosperity.

For example, a major American company Boeing relied on Russian production for a part called a “heat exchanger” which no other country could supply to meet its demands after sanctions were imposed following the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This one big US company highlights how interdependent the globalised world economy is. Boeing remains the most strategic American company maintaining an edge in aerospace technology due to its military and commercial component. It inevitably leads in the production and supply of military aircraft and civilian aerospace whose strength enable the US to be powerful among its allies, hence enhancing its global alliances. Other than Boeing, many other companies found themselves forced to suddenly close shop and abandon Russia, or retain a skeletal entity in the country.

As for Boeing, the fact that the sanctions on Russia caused severe problems for such an essential strategic American industry highlights the ‘contradiction in American geopolitical and economic strategy: sanctions programmes are designed to hobble foreign economies, but the Russian sanctions increasingly appear to be hobbling Western economies.’ Although American legislators can tolerate the destruction of some US companies in an attempt to punish Russia, it is European and British companies, critical industries and citizens that had to endure high energy prices caused by the Russian sanctions. Thus, the Russian economy is equally large and can only be compared to the Germany economy, hence not easy to just pull away from. Russian economy is part of the entangled global economy as it has essential sectors such as energy and aerospace.


If Russia is such a big economy, it is incomprehensible what similar sanctions to China would do. In addition, the EU is importing more of its capital goods from the BRICS economies than China imports from the Western countries. For example, responding to American sanctions on advanced semiconductors to China, the Chinese government reiterated by putting two export elements, germanium and gallium on a restricted export list. This effectively affected American economy as China produces 60% of the world’s germanium and 80% of its gallium, which are critically required for the production of electronic products such as microchips.


Fed up with the Western sanctions and being treated like colonies, most African states [Zimbabwe, Mali, Burkina Faso, South Africa, etc] have turned their backs on the West and engaged the BRICS or bilaterally with China, Russia, India and other emerging power houses. The result is that the West has locked itself out of what made it strong; cheap unregulated African resources, facilities and raw materials such as timber, minerals, land and military bases. The Alliance of Sahel states have ejected Western powers’ armies, notably former colonial power, France, and the US. Even the ECOWAS in Africa was coerced into imposing economic sanctions on the Sahel states hoping they will be crippled and change the coup governments, instead the three popular military regimes united and formed an Alliance of Sahel states.

THE MOST COMPREHENSIVE ‘GLOBAL’ ECONOMIC SANCTIONS ON RUSSIA HAVE FAILED?
Pilkington (2022) stated that, ‘The reason for this is simple and well-known: the rouble is a petrocurrency. That means it rises and falls with the price of oil. Oil prices are high due to the sanctions, and these high prices are driving the rouble higher. The sanctions themselves are driving the price of oil upwards; this in turn is driving the rouble skyward. Russia is becoming richer as we are becoming poorer. Any remotely competent energy economist could have told you that the sanctions would drive the price of oil up.’
Thus, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and economic sanctions imposed on it rightfully renewed political and academic discussion about the effectiveness and relevance of sanctions as a foreign policy tool. Although Western sanctions have taken a toll on many parts of the Russian economy, Russia has effectively evaded or adapted to the sanctions. Amazingly but not surprising, Russian economy grew by 3.6 percent (higher than the U.S. or EU growth rates) in 2023, and went on to triple its defence budget from pre-invasion levels.

In addition, in with sanctions aimed to isolate Russia, it has inversely grown closer to other nations enduring US and western sanction; including North Korea, Iran, and Venezuela. Furthermore, its recent hosting of BRICS member countries showed that it has defied US and western isolation and proved that sanctions are not necessarily and effective foreign policy against other nations. In contrast, those imposing sanctions end up losing on resources that once made them strong and they get replaced by other powers. The West’s contentious relationship with Africa is a very good example of the western powers losing access and influence in the former colonies and other emerging powers filling in the vacuum.

CONCLUSION
Economic sanctions are used as a foreign policy weapon mainly against poorer countries by the US and its allies and those other countries they are able to bully and blackmail by threatening to withdraw aid or loans. Economic sanctions tend to have more adverse impact on the innocent civilians than the political elite. At times, the sanctions have hurt those imposing them as seen with the Russian case, and again the West losing access to African raw materials and resources to other emerging nations. In some cases, economic sanctions have not been successful at all as has been the case with Russia. In addition, sanctions have strengthened animosity against the US unilateral policy that it imposes on other nations to implement. Sanctions have inevitably left the US’ economy vulnerable as other strong economies like China and India are challenging it.

Further Reading:
Choonara I, Bonati M, Jonas P (2021) Economic sanctions on countries are indiscriminate weapons and should be banned BMJ Paediatrics Open 2021;5:e001350. doi: 10.1136/bmjpo-2021-001350

Dendere, C – 2022, Zimbabwe: The Long Shadow of Sanctions

Pilkington, P 2022) ‘The West’s self-defeating sanctions’ The Critic
Masters, J (2024) What are Economic Sanctions? Council on Foreign Relations



Please follow and like us:
Pin Share
0

Comments

comments

About Author

Correspondent

@News Of The South, @Southern African news, @ South News today, @ Breaking News, @Africa News today, @Latest News, @African And Diaspora News, @Zimbabwean News, @Zimbabwe latest news, @World News, @Latest World News, @ News, @Latest news Of The South, @News Of The South Zimbabwe, @ Breaking News Of The South, @Southern News today live, @Harare news

Like Us On Facebook

SUBSCRIBE: YouTube Channel

Ad

Recent Comments